Paddles, not pedals. That's the way Formula One cars shift gears, and the technology has slowly trickled down to production models. In the ranks of thirty-something thousand dollar sports cars, two players currently offer the option of shifting when you please, while saving your left foot for walking. Audi introduced their Direct Shift Gearbox to the TT 3.2, and BMW brought out their Sequential Manual Gearbox as a mid-model year addition to the 2003 lineup.
The roll-out of SMG brings the transmission count to four in the Z4 lineup, out-distancing the engine choices by a factor of two. The $34,295 base roadster gets a 2.5 liter, inline six, rated at 184 hp, 175 lb. ft. of torque. The 2.5 with five speed manual is capable of a 7.1 second, 0-60 time, with a top speed of 146 mph. Dial up the sticker to $41,595, and the engine choice becomes a 3.0 liter six, with 225 hp, and 214 lb. ft. of torque. The 3.0i with six speed manual posts of 0-60 best of 5.9 seconds, and a governed top end of 155 mph.
The five and six speed manual gearboxes are standard issue on the 2.5 and 3.0., respectively, and both engines can be had with optional five speed automatic Steptronic or six speed Sequential Manual. My test car was a 2.5i with SMG.
BMW's 2.5 is a polished performer, with a wide, well stocked power band. Though the 3.0s' added muscle is enticing, we think most drivers would be very happy to drive the 2.5 and pocket the $7,300 difference.
- BMW 128
- BMW 135
- BMW 228
- BMW 228 Gran Coupe
- BMW 230
- BMW 318
- BMW 320
- BMW 323
- BMW 325
- BMW 328
- BMW 328 Gran Turismo
- BMW 328d
- BMW 330
- BMW 330 Gran Turismo
- BMW 330e
- BMW 335
- BMW 335 Gran Turismo
- BMW 335d
- BMW 340
- BMW 340 Gran Turismo
- BMW 428
- BMW 428 Gran Coupe
- BMW 430
- BMW 430 Gran Coupe
- BMW 435
- BMW 435 Gran Coupe
- BMW 440
- BMW 440 Gran Coupe
- BMW 525
- BMW 528
- BMW 530
- BMW 530e
- BMW 535
- BMW 535 Gran Turismo
- BMW 535d
- BMW 540
- BMW 540d
- BMW 545
- BMW 550
- BMW 550 Gran Turismo
- BMW 640
- BMW 640 Gran Coupe
- BMW 640 Gran Turismo
- BMW 645
- BMW 650
- BMW 650 Gran Coupe
- BMW 740
- BMW 740e
- BMW 745
- BMW 745e
- BMW 750
- BMW 760
- BMW 840
- BMW 840 Gran Coupe
- BMW ActiveHybrid 3
- BMW ActiveHybrid 5
- BMW ActiveHybrid 7
- BMW ActiveHybrid 740
- BMW ActiveHybrid 750
- BMW ActiveHybrid X6
- BMW ALPINA B6 Gran Coupe
- BMW ALPINA B7
- BMW ALPINA B8 Gran Coupe
- BMW ALPINA XB7
- BMW i3
- BMW i4
- BMW i8
- BMW iX
- BMW M
- BMW M2
- BMW M235
- BMW M235 Gran Coupe
- BMW M240
- BMW M3
- BMW M340
- BMW M4
- BMW M440
- BMW M440 Gran Coupe
- BMW M5
- BMW M550
- BMW M6
- BMW M6 Gran Coupe
- BMW M760
- BMW M8
- BMW M8 Gran Coupe
- BMW M850
- BMW M850 Gran Coupe
- BMW X1
- BMW X2
- BMW X3
- BMW X3 M
- BMW X3 PHEV
- BMW X4
- BMW X4 M
- BMW X5
- BMW X5 eDrive
- BMW X5 M
- BMW X5 PHEV
- BMW X6
- BMW X6 M
- BMW X7
- BMW Z3
- BMW Z4
- BMW Z4M
- BMW Z8
2004 BMW Z4 2.5i SMG
Paddle Pushers
Page 2: Quad burn
SMG has its roots in racing. This is shifting sans clutch, accomplished in either an automated or manual mode, with normal or sport settings. As a manual, the driver gets from cog to cog by one of two methods. You either access the twin, steering wheel mounted paddles (pull to shift up, push to downshift), or tap the center console mounted lever. Using the sport mode setting and with a little finessing of paddles and throttle, you can run the gearbox rapidly. Every time I am stuck chugging through a major metro area in a manual transmission car, I am reminded of why many city dwellers buy automatics. A regular diet of pumping clutches can get tedious. For that reason, the appeal of SMG is obvious - the fun and control of picking your own gears, without the quad burning workouts. In automated mode, the car does the shifting, but here, the case for SMG become less clear. Selecting sport mode will hold you in gear longer, but the shifts occur with a noticeable lag. By comparison, Audi's twin-clutch DSG is quicker and smoother in auto setting. More importantly, so is BMW's fully automatic Steptronic, and maybe even the manual gearbox, given a coordinated driver. Though the SMG offers the novel, no clutch option, we think most drivers will ultimately be happier with either of BMW's traditional transmission choices. As for me, I'd pick the smooth five-speed stick, take the $1,500 that you'd pay for SMG and buy a different option or two. That sum will get you, for instance, the premium sound system and xenon headlights ($1,575), or almost all of the Navigation system ($1,800, smart but hard to see in some lighting conditions).
Page 3: SMG
The SMG intro appeared as a rolling option at mid year '03. As to other changes for 2004, the steering wheel picked up redundant controls for the sound system. Windshield wipers are now rain sensing and automatic headlight control is also standard. Leather interiors are offered in a new hue - Dream Red/Black - and the Z4 is prepped for a removable hard top, which is also on the option sheet. Elsewise, all with Z4 is status quo. The interior is clean and well appointed. It is also understated, but if you'd like to turn up the visual volume, the two-tone options mix nicely with the brushed metalwork and low-key layout. The trunk is big enough to stand up to a weekend trip or (with top up) a couple of golf bags (you might have to slide the drivers in separately). The convertible top is well lined, fully automatic and has a heated glass backlight.
No matter what power train you pick, the platform remains the same and you'll hear no complaints about that. The chassis is stiff, weight balance is 50/50, suspension and steering beautifully dialed in. Ride quality is firm but stops short of harsh, and the brakes just plain stop short.
A finely balanced package, in a controversial wrapper. More edgy than pretty, the roadster marries classic sports car dimensions to radical chic sheet metal. Some will love it, some will hate it, no one will be indifferent. More than a year after its début, the Z4's slash cut styling is still inspiring debate, which might be one reason why BMW took the polarizing path in the first place. There's little debate on the basics, though. The Z4 is a finely tuned sports car with a pair of sweet six engines, and the capacity to be as shifty as you wanna be.
No matter what power train you pick, the platform remains the same and you'll hear no complaints about that. The chassis is stiff, weight balance is 50/50, suspension and steering beautifully dialed in. Ride quality is firm but stops short of harsh, and the brakes just plain stop short.
A finely balanced package, in a controversial wrapper. More edgy than pretty, the roadster marries classic sports car dimensions to radical chic sheet metal. Some will love it, some will hate it, no one will be indifferent. More than a year after its début, the Z4's slash cut styling is still inspiring debate, which might be one reason why BMW took the polarizing path in the first place. There's little debate on the basics, though. The Z4 is a finely tuned sports car with a pair of sweet six engines, and the capacity to be as shifty as you wanna be.
Page 4: FAQS
What is SMG's relationship with Formula 1?
SMG was pioneered in Formula 1 competition and is predominant in that sport today.Why is SMG popular?
It offers a new kind of actively enjoyable driving, and fascinating new things for an enthusiast driver to learn. Plus, there's the fun and control of picking your own gears, without the quad burning workouts.
How many transmissions are available in the Z4 lineup?
The $34,295 base roadster gets a 2.5 liter, inline six, rated at 184 hp, 175 lb. ft. of torque. The 2.5 with five speed manual is capable of a 7.1 second, 0-60 time, with a top speed of 146 mph. Dial up the sticker to $41,595, and the engine choice becomes a 3.0 liter six, with 225 hp, and 214 lb. ft. of torque. The 3.0i with six speed manual posts of 0-60 best of 5.9 seconds, and a governed top end of 155 mph.
SMG was pioneered in Formula 1 competition and is predominant in that sport today.Why is SMG popular?
It offers a new kind of actively enjoyable driving, and fascinating new things for an enthusiast driver to learn. Plus, there's the fun and control of picking your own gears, without the quad burning workouts.
How many transmissions are available in the Z4 lineup?
The $34,295 base roadster gets a 2.5 liter, inline six, rated at 184 hp, 175 lb. ft. of torque. The 2.5 with five speed manual is capable of a 7.1 second, 0-60 time, with a top speed of 146 mph. Dial up the sticker to $41,595, and the engine choice becomes a 3.0 liter six, with 225 hp, and 214 lb. ft. of torque. The 3.0i with six speed manual posts of 0-60 best of 5.9 seconds, and a governed top end of 155 mph.
Page 5: Notes
Test Vehicle: 2004 BMW Z4 2.5i SMG
MSRP: $33,100
As tested: $45,885Showroom appeal: BMW balance in two seat roadster form
Plus: Smooth six, well sorted chassis, styling
Minus: SMG shift lag in auto mode, styling
The Competition: Nissan 350Z, Porsche Boxster, Audi TT, Mercedes-Benz SLK, Chrysler Crossfire
MSRP: $33,100
As tested: $45,885Showroom appeal: BMW balance in two seat roadster form
Plus: Smooth six, well sorted chassis, styling
Minus: SMG shift lag in auto mode, styling
The Competition: Nissan 350Z, Porsche Boxster, Audi TT, Mercedes-Benz SLK, Chrysler Crossfire
- Back
- Page 1 of 5
- Next
- Next Article
Cars featured in this article
2004 BMW Z4
Learn more