MINI Cooper S Ratings

Getting firsthand information from an actual car owner is one sure way to get an idea of car performance once it leaves the lot. Autobytel features real consumer reviews that give the unbiased experience of a car.

Choose Your Vehicle -
Search Car Ratings for MINI
MINI Cooper S All Years
    • Overall
    • Comfort
    • Performance
    • Quality
    • Appearance

    2004 MINI Cooper S

    Baby

    Pros: The overall gestalt of the thing.

    Cons: Run flat tires are very expensive and don't wear too well - but certainly grip and go.

    The MINI S is both way hot and way cool, a banger and a pleasure car, my truck for hauling (on the sturdy and cute roof rack and in the back (seats down). Good sound system, often playing very loud. Would be a chick magnet if I were 40 years younger, I think. Even so it's a head turner, and really impresses my grandkids. Seems very well made, solid and sturdy after six years with no problems. Handles as well as any car I've driven, including some fairly big guys. But hate the run flats. I'd trade some handling for high end conventional tires and a 'canned air' flat fixer.

    • Recommend this vehicle to a friend? Yes
    • How long have you owned this vehicle? 5 years
    • Overall
    • Comfort
    • Performance
    • Quality
    • Appearance

    2006 MINI Cooper S

    High maintenance after first three years.

    Pros: Quick and easy to drive. Supercharger is great, but gas mileage is low, almost the same as my wife's cross over.

    Cons: High vibration

    Although there is no maintenance costs for the first three years, the maintenance schedule is little and far between. Oil is changed once a year or whenever the mileage count down indicates. The placement of the air conditioner is low in the engine compartment where road grim and water spray affects the switch that engages the high speed fan causing the fan to cycle on and off every minute or so. I've chnaged my system three times since I've owned my Mini. Further the road noise it transmitted into the passenger compartment to a much greater extent than other vehicles. The vibration through the suspension causes damage as well. I've had to replace my motor mounts, and either due to mechanic error or excessive vibration, the oil receptical where the filter is attached cracked. The could have been due to mechanic error as it only began after I had an oil change. Replacing the motor mounts and correcting the oil leak was in the $4000 range. Finally, Mini of Hawaii doesn't have a viewing area so you can watch what the mechanics are doing, so you don't have an opportunity to watch them put minor scratches and dings in the car as they work. They do road test, but they must really drive hard because I've picked up my car only to notice new checks in the edges of my rims. The car is very hard on tires. I' tend to change my tires every 8 months. The act of tire changing is another problem as they always scratch my rims. That has lead to a secondary business of rim repair.

    • Recommend this vehicle to a friend? No
    • How long have you owned this vehicle? 4 years
    • Overall
    • Comfort
    • Performance
    • Quality
    • Appearance

    2005 MINI Cooper S

    MINI Cooper's One Major Flaw

    Pros: Precise

    Cons: Unable to by transmission parts.

    I love this car. It has one major flaw. This flaw was discovered when an aftermarket part failed and damaged my transmission. MINI does NOT sell replacement parts for the transmission, if any thing goes wrong you have to replace the whole transmission! This makes out of warranty transmission problems VERY Expensive. This is a flawed company policy that will keep me from recommending this car to friends and family.

    • Recommend this vehicle to a friend? No
    • How long have you owned this vehicle? 5 years
    • Overall
    • Comfort
    • Performance
    • Quality
    • Appearance

    2006 MINI Cooper S

    Afternoon Drive Therapy

    Pros: Converitible top

    Cons: small trunk

    Surprisingly roomy, just plain fun. Very quick with great handling and pretty good accelleration. Can take driver and three others fairly comfortably for short distances. Continues to elicit positive comments from onlookers. Negatives include thin paint, small trunk. It's been a blast and I would get another one.

    • Recommend this vehicle to a friend? Yes
    • How long have you owned this vehicle? 4 years
    • Overall
    • Comfort
    • Performance
    • Quality
    • Appearance

    2008 MINI Cooper S - Hatchback

    Pros: 6 speed, very quick and sporty

    Cons: ahhhh, dont know . the payment

    Advice: great investment

    i love my mini, very well worth the price . recommended highly

    • Overall
    • Comfort
    • Performance
    • Quality
    • Appearance

    2008 MINI Cooper S - Hatchback

    Pros: The manual transmission.

    Cons: Not driving it enough.

    Advice: If you aren't sure, test drive it. Your mind will be made up.

    I have only owned this car for two days, so my quality ratings are just that - two days. This is by far the most fun car I have owned. It is the first imported car I have owned, and I am amazed. This car sticks to the road like glue, has amazing pick up speed for a 4-cylinder engine - for any engine actually, and gets great gas mileage to boot. It's too bad the engineers at Chevrolet/Ford/Chrysler can't get together and come up with a vehicle like this. I'll try and add more as time passes, but this is one amazing car. If you're considering a purchase, go ahead... you won't be disappointed. Oh, I've seen some comments about resale value. Every used Mini I looked at was over $20,000, so I would say they actually have great resale value. If you know how do drive one, I recommend the 6-speed manual!

    • Overall
    • Comfort
    • Performance
    • Quality
    • Appearance

    2008 MINI Cooper S - Convertible

    Pros: convertible top

    Cons: run flats ... expensive to replace and flat tire light ... very sensitive

    Advice: Go to the Mini USA site and design the one you want, dealers will work with you or order the exact one you want!

    Awesome car! Fun to drive and surprisingly enough very roomy ... at least in the front seat. I LOVE this car.