Facebook Logo Facebook Logo 2 Twitter Logo i_gplus i_copyurl i_plus i_minus i_reddit i_envelope search youtube-play feed2 user-tie arrow-right-thick location icon-wagons icon-diesel icon-hatchback icon-hybrid enlarge shrink camera

BMW M5 Ratings

Getting firsthand information from an actual car owner is one sure way to get an idea of car performance once it leaves the lot. Autobytel features real consumer reviews that give the unbiased experience of a car.

Choose Your Vehicle -
Search Car Ratings for BMW
BMW M5 All Years
    • Overall
    • Comfort
    • Performance
    • Quality
    • Appearance

    5/24/2007 5:45:45 AM

    2007 BMW M5 - Base

    Pros: Heads up display

    Cons: Too many things to list

    Advice: Look somewhere else

    Buyer beware: There’s a reason for all those mediocre reviews out there in the automotive press. In truth, many of the reviews sound as though the writers think even less of the car than what they actually write, but are reluctant to bash a car with the reputation of the M5. Well that reputation was built from the first three US models. This one is fundamentally different. This is a Mercedes posing as a BMW. Its all about speed and comfort and lacks the handling of the earlier cars. Its very heavy and you feel every pound. It about cruising; not about flogging down a twisty road in the countryside. You feel disconnected from the road, there is no sense of immediacy on turn in. Every bit of feedback is filtered through a layer of electronics. This is my fourth M car and the first one I am really disappointed in.

    • Overall
    • Comfort
    • Performance
    • Quality
    • Appearance

    11/22/2005 3:38:57 PM

    2002 BMW M5 - Base

    Pros: The Power!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Cons: Wish the seat was a little wider.

    Advice: Hang on!!!

    This is the most fun you can have in four doors. I love the shift from second to third, amazing power. Clutch and steering are incredible. Car feels like it is on rails at all speeds. Only complaint is making smooth take offs at high speed. Seats are very comfortable but I am very tall and wide and they could be a bit wider in the seat for me.

    • Overall
    • Comfort
    • Performance
    • Quality
    • Appearance

    8/5/2002 10:07:12 PM

    2002 BMW M5 - Base

    Pros: M label

    Cons: suspenion too soft when you need fast corning

    Advice: get ACS parts to make it perfect

    a Sedan doesn't need 400bhp and stick shift. So if need this car to perform better, the suspension must be upgraded. Firmer and lower the suspension by an inch to make the car totally diferent. Stock pipes are heavy, fit DINAN or ACS give better sound and look.

    • Overall
    • Comfort
    • Performance
    • Quality
    • Appearance

    3/31/2002 8:02:18 PM

    2002 BMW M5 - Base

    Pros: Overall performance

    Cons: Thats a tough one

    Advice: Self restraint when driving

    Simply put, the most awesome sedan on the road today. I went to a Porsche Club track event and opened their eyes. The only close competition came from 996 twin turbos and an RS 3.8. I was a Porsche owner for 30 years. I have gone to the dark side of the force now and hardly ever look back. When I do I see Porsches in the rearview. The M5 is that incredible. I know some car company will come up with more horsepower, but I doubt they will match the total balance of Power, torque, cornering, stopping, and comfort. When God said 'let there be automobiles', this is what he meant.